Move from Expert Wisdom to Crowd Wisdom

I found this week’s readings fascinating and had to go through all the articles about group think, wisdom, etc.  It makes sense that if you put together a diverse group of people who are applying their expertise and providing a new viewpoint towards a problem, as in the case Goldcorp mentioned by Tapscott and Williams, new solutions are bound to pop up.  However, Jenkins’ article makes an important distinction between collective intelligence and the wisdom of crowds.  In Surowiecki’s Wisdom of Crowds anonymous data is gathered from a large group of people who are not influenced by each other where as Levy’s Collective Intelligence theory focuses on large groups of people who are sharing information and collaborating to come up with a solution.

I can see both models having positive and negative aspects.  For the Surowiecki model one does not have to worry that someone with a strong ability to influence others is skewing the data coming out of a scenario and therefore producing less accurate data.  However, since this group of people have no interaction they also lose the ability to discuss and build on top of each others ideas and possibly coming up with a better solution.  In comparison Levy’s collective intelligence approach literally has a group of people working together, sharing information and coming up with a solution.  The main problem there is that some people can have too much of an influence on others without data to support their stance and thus can skew the results.

Both concepts have their place in problem solving and when utilizing the ideas in the work space they can be successfully implemented.  Hence, the plethora of committees, councils, anonymous surveys, etc.  The key is to recognize when to use each theory and ensure it is appropriate to the situation.

Tapscott, D and Williams, A. (2007). “Innovation in the Age of Mass Collaboration.”

Business Week. Jenkins, H. (2006). “Collective Intelligence vs. The Wisdom of Crowds.”

This entry was posted in LIBR246 and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to Move from Expert Wisdom to Crowd Wisdom

  1. Hi Debbie,
    First let me say what a great post. I like how you’re able to summarize everything so clearly and concisely. You touched some issues that I found very interesting. I too liked the readings for this week especially the “Collective Intelligence vs The Wisdoms of Crowds”. I just found this reading very interesting because I think that organizations can benefit more through Wisdom of crowds methods when it’s used properly. I feel that gathering information from groups that are not influenced by each other gives us a wider less bias perspective. I really like your conclusion about recognizing when to use each theory.
    Anyways, thanks for the great read and I look forward to reading your next posts.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s